Bugles: Commemorative Replicas
There are far more replica bugles than historic military bugles in the community. Usually made in India or Pakistan, commemorative replica bugles may honour an event, battle, unit, or family member. Some are of good enough quality to be played at Anzac Day or Remembrance Day ceremonies, and can provide a special addition to the atmosphere.
However, since entering the public domain many have lost their identities as commemorative items and have been mistakenly identified as genuine military bugles, with historic links to specific battles, units, or wartime events.
Questions to ask when looking at a bugle
While distinguishing between military bugles and replicas is not an exact science, the below questions can help. Some examples of replica commemorative bugles are also listed below.
Does this bugle have a known history?
Possibly the most important task when attempting to confirm a bugle’s authenticity is finding out the “who”, “what”, “where”, and “when” of its military history.
A soldered badge or stamped inscription detailing a person, unit, or event on a bugle is no guarantee that it is genuine, as commemorative bugles also have these.
Some historic military bugles feature personal inscriptions, or an inscription for a unit if it was presented before embarkation, which are usually engraved rather than stamped. Information about the presentation of these bugles can sometimes be located by searching contemporary newspapers on the Trove website.
Does it have a maker’s mark?
Genuine military bugles have maker’s marks, usually on the lower front of the bell, which include the maker’s details and year the bugle was made. If the bugle was issued by the Department of Defence (rather than presented by an organisation or community) it will also have a Defence mark: a broad arrow; a “D” with a broad arrow; a “D [broad arrow] D” mark; or, if supplied by the British War Department, “W D” with a broad arrow.
Is there a badge soldered to the bugle where the maker’s mark should be?
Most replica bugles have badges soldered to the lower front where the manufacturer’s details should be, covering up the fact the maker’s details are missing. Some replica bugles do not have a soldered badge and instead feature a commemorative inscription where the maker’s mark should be.
Australian military bugles do not traditionally have badges soldered to them. While there may be genuine bugles which have had badges attached post war, in these instances a maker’s mark can still be seen, and the bugle will have a recorded history with a serviceman or unit, and be identifiable as genuine despite the addition.
Most replica badges are sand cast copies which do not look at crisp as the corresponding die struck original badges. One exception is where they have copied unofficial original badges (such as the 13th Light Horse’s “dancing devil” badge), which were also usually sand cast. Replica badges often feature poorer definition and much thinner brass than original badges.
two crossed rifles used on a Gallipoli bugle
What is the quality of the inscription?
The quality of stamped inscriptions on replica commemorative bugles is usually low, which along with a sand cast badge can give a bugle a “trench art” feel that contributes to its aura of authenticity.
Some may have double stampings, where a letter has been struck twice in one spot, and some letters or numbers may appear out of order or not be fully pressed into the bell. The Camel Corps bugle, for example, features an incomplete “B” in “MAGDHABA”, looking more like an “R”, and the text is incorrectly recorded in descriptions as reading “MAGDHARA”.
Below is an image of the inscription from a Kokoda commemorative bugle. Some letters have been double struck, other have not been struck properly, and unusual lower case letters (in this case “i”) have been used, whereas the First and Second AIF used upper case letter dies (courtesy of S Medforth)
What does the mouth piece look like?
Replica bugles often have poor quality mouthpieces and it can be difficult to get a good sound from a replica bugle. Original bugle mouthpieces are sometimes nickel plated and may have maker’s marks and Defence markings on them. In some instances where the nickel has started to wear away, evidence of its former presence is still apparent. If a bugle has been used over many years it may have a replacement mouth piece.
What is it made from? What is the bugle’s finish?
Unless highly polished, replica bugles can have a patina that makes them look old, but they don’t always show the sort of damage that would be expected of a military bugle that had survived a war. The patina of replicas is artificially applied and as a result often appears spotty. A genuine bugle (if it hasn’t been polished) will usually have an overall dull brown colour.
Some replica bugles are chromed. While there are examples of genuine military bugles that were chromed post war (which, as with genuine bugles with badges attached post war, have known histories and makers), Australian military bugles are generally not silver in colour.
Below is an image of a genuine bugle that has been chromed post war. You can tell it is genuine by the maker’s information on the front and because it has a known association with a serviceman.
Does the bugle have cords?
Replicas may have cords (called “strings” by the military) that are often made from nylon. Being synthetic, they tend to be shinier than original historical cords, and are often multi-coloured, such as red and gold; blue, white and red; or red, gold and black – not the colours used by the Australian Army during war (usually green).
How much does it weigh?
Replicas often weigh between 100 and 350 grams lighter than genuine bugles. A genuine bugle weighs around 600–800 grams, while replicas weigh around 300–600 grams (depending on quality and if it has cords).
Australian themed commemorative bugles
The bugles detailed below are commemorative replicas, multiple examples of which have been sighted, or which have been identified by sales information acknowledging them as replicas. This list is not exhaustive, but certain features are evident that are common in replica bugles.
Victorian Mounted Rifles, Boer War
Stamped “VICTORIAN MOUNTED RIFLES BOAR WAR 1899 – 1902” (note the misspelling of “Boer”).
Stamped “GALLIPOLI LANDING DARDANELLES APRIL 25TH 1915”. These replica bugles sometimes have a badge soldered to the bell beneath the inscription. If there is no badge, the inscription is located where the maker’s mark would be for a genuine military bugle.
ANZAC Great War
Stamped “ANZAC GREAT WAR 1914–1918” above a Rising Sun badge and a curved “AUSTRALIA” shoulder title.
AIF Battle Honours
Stamped “A.I.F. BATTLE HONOURS 1914–1918 GALLIPOLI MIDDLE EAST WESTERN FRONT” above a Rising Sun badge.
Imperial Camel Corps
Stamped “CAMEL CORPS MAGDHABA BATTLE 23rd DECEMBER 916”.
As previously mentioned, most examples of this bugle sighted are poorly stamped and “MAGHDABA” looks like “MAGHDARA”. The year 1916 is often incorrectly stamped, sometimes appearing as “116”, or with other numbers appearing after the “6”.
The Rising Sun badge is overlaid by a poor quality sand cast camel (which is made of a different metal) and gaps between the two can be seen.
Stamped “4TH AUSTRALIAN LIGHT HORSE CHARGE OF BEERSHEBA 31ST OCTOBER 1917”, “AUSTRALIAN LIGHT HORSE CHARGE OF BEERSHEBA 31ST OCTOBER 1917”, or “AUSTRALIAN LIGHT HORSE CHARGE AT BEERSHEBA OCTOBER 31 1917″. Some examples have badges affixed below the inscription while others have an inscription where the maker’s mark should be.
13th Light Horse Regiment
Stamped “13TH AUSTRALIAN LIGHT HORSE”. The unofficial 13th Light Horse badge with a “dancing devil” is attached to the bugle below the inscription.
23rd Light Horse Regiment
Stamped “LIGHT HORSE 23RD BAROSSA VALLEY 1930–1942”, above the 23rd Light Horse Regiment badge featuring a horse’s head in front of two crossed swords.
Rats of Tobruk
Stamped "AUSTRALIA 9THDIVISION OF TOBRUK 1941" above a Rising Sun badge and a curved “AUSTRALIA” shoulder title.
Stamped “KOKODA TRAil ViCTORY 942 39th BATTALION MILITIA 2nd A.i.F”, above a Rising Sun badge. The use of the lower case letter ‘i’ is particularly unusual. Contemporary die sets used by the military only contained upper case letters, which helps indicate this is a modern day commemorative replica.
Stamped “LONG TAN BATTLE VIETNAM WAR 18TH AUGUST 1966”, above the Infantry Corps badge. 6RAR did not use bugles at the Battle of Long Tan. While the Viet Cong did play bugles during the battle, these were of a different design to those used by the Australian Army.
West Australian University Regiment
These bugles have a unit badge soldered to the front and may have multi-coloured cords. They have been found in many countries, including the United Kingdom, America, and Chile. Information about this bugle is available on the West Australian University’s website.